West Indian Food Mart in Pickering is highly regarded by customers for its delicious Pakistani dishes, particularly the Nihari and Halwa Puri. The food is described as flavorful, delicious, and generous in portion size. Vegan and vegetarian options are also praised for their taste. Many reviewers recommend the meat combos and biryani. The prices are reasonable and the customer service is commended for being helpful and friendly. Some customers have also had positive experiences with catering services.