Fresh & Fancy Bakery receives high praise for professional service and exceptional baked goods, specifically the Pecan Tarts with melt-in-your-mouth pastry and Apple Fritters with magical texture and flavor. Sourdough bread and Chelsea buns are also frequently mentioned for their amazing quality. Apple fritters are a standout favorite and are described as huge with lots of apple chunks. The business has a long-standing reputation for delivering fresh and reasonably priced goods.